Skip to main content

A Meat-Lovers Vegetable Pizza – Caramelized Onions, Cremini Mushrooms and Goat Cheese

A Meat-Lovers Vegetable Pizza – Caramelized Onions, Cremini Mushrooms and Goat Cheese

By Suzanne Elizabeth Anderson

I can remember when Meatless Monday signaled sacrifice. I would struggle to come up with one dish that didn't taste like something I was doing as penance for the rest of the week.
Then, two years ago I had a brush with breast cancer. Overnight, my view of healthy eating became much more important.
Over the next two years, I collected cookbooks that followed this directive and because I love to cook and lack the discipline to live on a diet of raw food, I looked for ways to transform my favorite dishes into healthy, but satisfying, alternatives.
The experience was so gratifying that now at least four out of seven dinners per week are vegetarian and three meals allow my carnivore flag to fly.
Today's recipe is an example of that transformation. I love pizza. My favorite is a Chicago-style deep dish with sausage and mushrooms and more cheese by weight than all other ingredients. And yes, once a month, I still make that pizza, have a slice and then freeze the rest.
This pizza is topped with mushrooms, caramelized onions, and goat cheese. From my cursory google search, the health benefits of mushrooms include antioxidant selenium and vitamin D, and onions include vitamin C and chromium. Both mushrooms and onions have been linked to cancer fighting anti-inflammatories, lowered cholesterol, and heart health.
If you are used to eating a meat-lovers pizza, I think you'll find this recipe to be a good place to start. The brown Cremini mushrooms have a meaty texture. The caramelized onions add a rustic sweetness, that reminds us of coal-fired pizzas and grilled foods and provides a nice counterpoint to the sharp tang of the goat cheese. Best of all, it can be assembled, baked, and brought to the table quicker than you can you call for delivery. I challenge you to try it and tell me if isn't as satisfying as your usual take-out pizza.
Let's get started!
For the dough:
I like to make my own pizza dough and after you've done it few times, you'll do the same. There are few ingredients and it's fun. You can also buy pre-made dough in the deli section of many grocery stores.
Here's my basic recipe:
1 1/2 cups warm water - stir in 2 1/2 teaspoons (or 1 packet) dry yeast and 1 teaspoon sugar, mix well and let proof for a few minutes until the water becomes cloudy and begins to bubble. This should take about 45 minutes. If you’re in a hurry, many grocery stores carry a fast-acting yeast specifically for pizza dough which will allow the dough to be ready in 5 minutes.

Mix the dry ingredients together in a large bowl:
2 cups of All-Purpose Flour
1/4 cup cornmeal (this addition is optional, but it gives the dough a nice texture)
1/2 teaspoon salt
Gradually pour the water into the flour mixture, stirring until you've added enough liquid to create a sticky dough. Pour a tablespoon of oil over the dough and coat, so the dough doesn't dry out. Cover with plastic wrap or a clean dishtowel and let rise in a warm spot until doubled. Then, gently stretch the dough out until it resembles a large rectangle which will fill most of a standard cookie sheet. I like to place my dough on parchment paper so that I don't have to worry about it sticking to my well worn cookie sheets. 
Preheat the oven to 450F
For the pizza topping:
4 onions sliced into thin-medium rounds, will be gently and slowly caramelized in 2 tablespoons of butter and oil over a medium heat, stirring frequently to prevent burning. A pinch of sugar will help the caramelization process.
1 pint of Cremini mushrooms (or mushrooms of your choice) will be thinly sliced and join the onions to be sautéed in the butter.
Salt and pepper to taste.
When they are cooked, add them to the top of the pizza dough, sprinkle the pizza with crumbles of your favorite goat cheese (an herbed goat cheese would be nice here) 
Bake for 10-13 minutes...depending on how well done you like the crust.
A nice finishing touch is to drizzle a balsamic glaze over the top of the pizza.
Serve with a salad and a heart-healthy glass of red wine.
Bon Appetit! 

This Week's Book Recommendation:
Home Cooked - Essential Recipes for a New Way to Cook
by Anya Fernald
 If you care about where your food comes from, you should meet Anya Fernald or at least read her new cookbook. Anya is one of the pioneers of the Slow Food and sustainable food movement and she is now the CEO of Belcampo a 200 acre cattle farm and meat processor in Northern California. 
Home Cooked lives up to its name. Everything from bone broth, to eggs in tomato sauce, to almond torta are beautifully photographed and lovingly described in accessible recipes.
Anya's familiarity with meat brings us braised  tripe, grilled pork belly with anchovies, and several recipes for homemade sausage.
Vegetarians will also find much to love here with eggplant caponata, torta di verdure made with whatever greens look the best at the farmer's market, blackened carrots, or squash and faro risotto.
I highly recommend this book for those who love to cook from scratch and enjoy preparing food that allows the ingredients to be the star.
I received this cookbook for free from in exchange for an honest review.
Please leave a comment or send me an email if there is a recipe you'd like me to try.
See you next week!
Suzanne Elizabeth. 
Suzanne Elizabeth Anderson writes weekly food and religion columns for the Summit Daily News and is the author of ten books. You can find her at


Popular posts from this blog

When our spirit hungers

The precocious toddler’s interest in talking to her mother grew in insistence as the gathered group settled in for an hour of silent prayer. Shushing didn’t work, so the mother led her child into an adjoining room where she would still be part of the sanctuary, but sound would be dampened. Despite the closed door and heavy glass walls, the child’s fervent desire to speak with her mother was still audible.
I said a prayer for the patient mother determined to stay, and for the child who was either tired or hungry or impatient for Mom’s undivided attention. And then tried to bring my wandering thoughts back to prayer. I had come to Adoration with my own pressing need for answers.
Over the past few weeks I’ve noticed a growing emptiness in my heart. A void, as if something is missing. It’s not psychological. Not physical. After doing an internal check, I determined it’s a spiritual void that I’m experiencing.
No, I’m not doubting God, his existence or goodness. I have full confidence in…

Open to the Spirit - Book Review

Open to the Sprit is like reading a letter from a friend. McKnight writes a very accessible introduction to the Holy Spirit and its role in our spiritual life. McKnight uses several stories from his life and others to share how the Holy Spirit consoles and deepens our daily spiritual walk. A terrific book for those seeking an introduction to a relationship with the Holy Spirit.

Simple Spinach and Kale Fettucine

On Wednesday I picked up my first box of organic from the High Country Conservation Center’s Summit CSA (Community Supported Agriculture). Way back in February, I bought a ‘share’ in this summer’s crop, which entitles me to a weekly box of organic vegetables from mid-June through October.

Now that the vegetables have arrived, I have two reactions: 1) Wow! This is so exciting! Look at these beautiful vegetables, I’m going to be so healthy. 2) Yikes! What am I going to do with four bags of greens?

For the next sixteen weeks, I want to share my culinary adventures as I cook my way through my CSA box each week. Even if you don’t subscribe to the CSA share, you’ll enjoy these recipes which focus on our summer bounty. I hope you’ll also be inspired to try more vegetable-centered meals. Now, back to those four bags of greens! 

This week’s recipe polished off two of the bags immediately. You can make this easy and tasty recipe for two or four people, just increase the amount of greens and th…